My gender has been an undeniable advantage for most of my journalism career.
I think I deserved every job or promotion and I think I’ve performed well in each job. But I know that I got more breaks and opportunities than deserving female colleagues. And male colleagues with less achievement and potential also got more breaks.
Nieman Reports has published a strong and detailed examination of gender issues in journalism. I encourage you to read it for a more thorough look at the issues and obstacles than you’ll find here. This is just a personal perspective, prompted by the Nieman report: Gender has been a significant – sometimes huge – obstacle for female journalists throughout my journalism career. While it has improved over the long haul, it hasn’t been steady improvement and I wouldn’t argue with anyone who said women have lost ground lately.
I’ve worked with a lot of male journalists who rose to upper-level management positions, or even to the top, who weren’t as talented or as accomplished as females who left the business in frustration or never made it to the upper levels.
For this post, I’m not going to name names or news organizations. I don’t want to offend or argue with former male colleagues I think have based decisions in large or tiny part on gender, intentionally or without thinking. I don’t want to embarrass any women by discussing their career disappointments or other matters. And I certainly won’t violate the things female colleagues have told me in confidence.
But here are some observations about gender in the newsrooms where I’ve worked, either as a full-time journalist or visiting as a trainer or corporate editor: Continue Reading »
Posted in diversity | Tagged diversity, Nieman Reports, sexism, women in journalism | 6 Comments »
My distracting laptop
I’ve updated this post after discussing the issue with my class.
I can think of no journalism professors I admire more than Clay Shirky and Jay Rosen. But I (so far) disagree with them on the subject of whether to allow students to use laptops and mobile devices during class.
Clay has explained in a blog post why he bans computers from his classroom. Jay chimed in his agreement:
They both have notably more classroom experience than I do, and they might be right. I encourage you to read Clay’s full explanation and won’t try to summarize it here, but he cites research about how multitasking can interfere with learning.
My limited experience is different. I was very glad yesterday that a student had her laptop and multitasked in class. Continue Reading »
Posted in Advice for a new professor, Journalism education | Tagged Clay Shirky, Jay Rosen, Journalism education, multitasking | 14 Comments »
If David Carr of the New York Times had documented more than a dozen incidents of apparent plagiarism by Fareed Zakaria, Zakaria probably would have lost his jobs with prominent media outlets.
But the accusations come from writers identified only by two odd-sounding Twitter handles. The substance of the accusations by @blippoblappo and @crushingbort in their blog Our Bad Media gets lost because we don’t know the accusers.
Zakaria gave Politico a response to the initial accusations from Our Bad Media, denying any wrongdoing, but not addressing the substance of most of the 12 instances cited in a Aug. 19 post on Our Bad Media. I have not seen any response from him to their latest post, detailing six more instances of apparent plagiarism from his best-selling book, The Post-American World.
Looking at the substance of the accusations — side-by-side images highlighting verbatim and closely similar passages between Zakaria’s work and sources he never or barely cited — the offenses are similar to the 2012 plagiarism from a Jill Lepore article in the New Yorker, which brought Zakaria a suspension from the three media outlets that featured his work then. I haven’t checked them all out beyond looking at those images, but the checks I have made validate the accusations, and I presume we would have heard if any of them were not accurate.
Continue Reading »
Posted in Ethics | Tagged anonymity, CNN, Fareed Zakaria, Our Bad Media, plagiarism, Time, Washington Post | 2 Comments »
In some emails last week and in my post on a workshop last Friday, I asked for examples of effective use of interactive storytelling tools.
Below are examples sent by some friends. I haven’t had a chance to check them all out, but I trust these friends’ judgment, so I pass them along enthusiastically. With the exception of Mike Reilley, all the examples come from my former colleagues at Digital First Media. I was seeking enterprise examples, but they sent interactive stories from a variety of situations. I think in many of these cases, other colleagues were involved. I wasn’t asking just for their own work, but for good work they had seen lately. With light editing, the list is pretty much what they sent me.
Buffy Andrews’ interactive stories
Buffy, assistant managing editor at the York Daily Record and a novelist, sent along these: Continue Reading »
Posted in Digital journalism tools, Digital storytelling | Tagged Buffy Andrews, C.J. Sinner, Dan Petty, Don Wyatt, Mike Reilley | Leave a Comment »
The Society of Professional Journalists adopted a new Code of Ethics Saturday at its meeting in Nashville.
I am pleased that SPJ updated a code that I described four years ago as profoundly outdated. But I’m disappointed that SPJ didn’t provide better leadership in this code.
Before I address my disappointments, I’ll say what pleases me:
Why I’m pleased
I’m pleased that SPJ has a more timely, relevant code. The code has been outdated for years, and I applaud progress. I’m pleased that the code mostly improved since I criticized the first draft in two lengthy blog posts in April and improved a bit more since I criticized the third draft in July. It even improved since Friday morning, when I was one of many during an Excellence in Journalism conference session who criticized the “final draft” that was approved by the Ethics Committee Aug. 28. In a Friday evening meeting, the SPJ Ethics Committee and Board adopted some of the changes suggested by Andy Schotz in a blog post and at Friday morning’s discussion. That I wish for more doesn’t change the fact that this is progress and I do appreciate that. Continue Reading »
Posted in Ethics | Tagged anonymous sources, confidential sources, journalism ethics, linking, plagiarism, Society of Professional Journalists, SPJ Code of Ethics | 3 Comments »
Update: The final draft of the code update was revised again yesterday. I like what I’ve heard about the changes, but I haven’t analyzed it yet.
I will be leading a session at the Excellence in Journalism conference today about the broader ethics discussion in journalism.
At the EIJ conference, the Society of Professional Journalists will vote on adoption of a new ethics code. Here is the latest draft of the code, though it could be amended in floor debate today. My criticism of the revision stands, and I won’t belabor it either in this post or in my EIJ session.
Other ethics initiatives I will discuss include:
Poynter’s Guiding Principles
The new Poynter Guiding Principles for the Journalist, published in the 2013 book, The New Ethics of Journalism, edited by Kelly McBride and Tom Rosenstiel. I blogged in 2012 from a Poynter event to discuss updating the Guiding Principles, then blogged again with suggestions for the new principles and in 2013 with praise and criticism for the completed guidelines. Among other changes, the guiding principles changed two of the three core values from the original Guiding Principles, authored by Bob Steele in the early 1990s. The 1990s principles were organized around the values of truthfulness, independence and minimizing harm. Now the core values are truthfulness, transparency and community. The 1990s SPJ Code and Guiding Principles were strongly similar, with SPJ using the same three core values, plus accountability (Bob dealt with accountability in his elaboration on the other values). In the final draft of the SPJ update, the core values are unchanged, except that transparency is paired with accountability in the last section. Continue Reading »
Posted in Ethics | Tagged Bob Steele, Craig Silverman, European Journalism Centre, fabrication, IRE Journal, J-Lab, Jay Rosen, journalism ethics, Kellie Riordan, Kelly McBride, Online News Association, plagiarism, Poynter, Radio Television Digital News Association, Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism, Rules of the Road, Scott Rosenberg, Society of Professional Journalists, SPJ Code of Ethics, Telling the Truth and Nothing But, The New Ethics of Journalism, Tom Kent, Tom Rosenstiel, University of Colorado, University of Oxford, Verification Handbook | 2 Comments »
I’ll be leading a workshop today on digital planning for enterprise stories at the Excellence in Journalism conference in Nashville.
Much of the workshop will revolve around the questions for planning enterprise stories that I blogged about earlier this year.
Other links relating to the workshop:
Five Satins: A ‘Sunday’ story published digitally the Monday before
‘In the Still of the Night': Five Satins recorded biggest hit in New Haven church basement
Sunshine Week project showed digital-first enterprise approach
Sunshine Week project
10 steps toward a mobile-focused culture for your news organisation
Denver Post’s Chasing the Beast
Denver Post’s The Fire Line
Nola.com’s then-and-now Hurricane Katrina photos
ProPublica Patient Harm Facebook group
Gettysburg 150 app
Cost of Dying app
Daniel Victor’s post on infusing community contribution throughout the reporting process
Carrie Jewell-Dugo project, story by Paula Ann Mitchell, photos by Tania Barricklo, design by Ivan Lajara, using Creatavist
Ed Stannard and Angi Carter interactive map on Yale’s tax-exempt property in New Haven
I’ll probably update this with some more examples. I welcome any you might want to suggest, whether by you, colleagues or competitors:
Here’s my first update, a Spundge from Buffy Andrews of the York Daily Record, explaining a variety of digital tools.
Here are my slides for the workshop (also subject to updating as I get more fresh examples):
Posted in Digital journalism tools, Digital storytelling | Tagged digital journalism, enterprise reporting, Excellence in Journalism | 4 Comments »