When I started in the newspaper business, “local news” often meant who was sick and who was visiting.
My first job as a journalist was at The Evening Sentinel, a daily newspaper of about 4,000 circulation in Shenandoah, Iowa, that went out of publication in the 1990s. I was a sports writer, covering the school teams in nearby towns even smaller than “Shen.”
Chuck Offenburger, the sports editor, and I filled some space in the back of the paper with game stories and features on local athletes. The front page reported big (for Shen) news such as the city council and school board actions and an occasional crime or court case. But the heart of the newspaper was what we called the “locals,” a string of one-paragraph tidbits giving updates on someone’s illness or telling whose kids were visiting from college or from the distant big cities where lots of Shen’s kids moved off to (and if you were in Shen, Cedar Rapids and Iowa City were big cities).
Some people called the locals in or brought them in (often handwritten and difficult to read) and a semi-retired editor named Bob Tindall rounded lots of them up on the phone, checking out tips that he had received from the town gossips, of which Shen had no shortage. In nearby towns such as Farragut, Coin and Randolph, “correspondents” (busybodies might have been a more accurate term) sent in the locals from their communities, again many of them handwritten.
As a youth who yearned to break bigger news in a big city somewhere, I was pretty scornful of the locals and glad when I made it to bigger papers that didn’t waste time or space on such trivial news.
I laughed heartily when the TV show “M*A*S*H” mocked the locals. Hawkeye Pierce would read weeks-old copies of the Crabapple Cove Courier, sent by his father back home in Maine. Of course, when the laughter died, those trivial tidbits of people’s lives from back home always aggravated Hawkeye’s homesickness and deepened his connection to home. (Remember, in the final episode, he was returning to Crabapple Cove, not heading off to a big hospital in the big city).
I’m learning now how vital those updates on ailing loved ones are. I’m seeing an opportunity that newspapers have missed. And I’m mulling what we can do to deepen people’s personal connections to their community.
I have a nephew in Vermont who is undergoing grueling chemotherapy treatment for leukemia. I’m his godfather, though we haven’t been very close geographically any time in his life and I haven’t stayed in touch enough with him and his family by letter, phone or email. But they visited us in Virginia a couple years ago. We visited them in Vermont last May. Patrick is in those adolescent years where changes are dramatic from one visit to the next: a few inches taller, a different hairstyle, a deeper voice, more engaged with the adult conversation as a youth strains to belong with the grown-ups.
I became an Eagle Scout almost 39 years ago, and Patrick has pursued Scouting harder than my sons, so that has been a bond over the miles of separation between intermittent visits. I showed him my patches when he was young and later traded him some of my patches from the 1960s for some of his from the 21st Century. When he went to Philmont Scout Ranch in New Mexico this summer, I followed his mountain-climbing updates from afar.
When we learned right before Christmas that Patrick had leukemia, the whole family was devastated. The news and the early updates traveled by telephone and email. But soon his parents set up a password-protected site on CaringBridge.org. We read the vital news about medical progress and the setbacks, the plans for a bone-marrow transplant, the side effects of the drugs. We read the mundane news of who visited today, what movies he watches and games he plays as he battles the boredom of a hospital (a greater challenge, I know, than any Philmont mountain). It keeps us connected to this distant loved one, just like old copies of the Crabappple Cove Courier did for Hawkeye.
CaringBridge is either a lost opportunity for newspapers or a huge challenge for any newspaper company seeking to reclaim that facet of personal news.
But those locals I used to scorn in the Sentinel told a lot of other news that was important in tiny circles: visits, travels, achievements, social meetings and so on. As Gazette Communications transforms our community information operation, we need to develop ways to help people connect and share this vital news of their lives that’s more important in smaller circles than the big stories on Page One.
I agree that this type of news that is mocked by bigger newspapers and journalists is the kind of stuff that people want to read. I’ve never had a problem with it and actually have found pretty good story ideas from correspondents’ articles.
LikeLike
I’m going to say this wrong, and I hope you read it right. It is tragic news about your nephew and my heart goes out to you and his family. This post is so on the money in many ways. I find out more about you — I too am an Eagle Scout and never got to go to Philmont, although I always wanted to — but more important you hit the mark about local. And about the challenge we have in giving people what they want. Well said.
LikeLike
Thanks, John. I think you said it right and I read it right.
LikeLike
I can relate to your earlier opinions about “chicken dinner” news Steve. Starting out in my hometown weekly newspaper I didn’t see the need or attraction of the content, but then again I wasn’t who the paper was trying to appeal to.
As I got older and still working in small weeklies in Iowa in Altoona, Dyersville and Cascade I quickly realized how necessary this type of content was to the makeup of the newspaper and how interwoven it is in the fabric of community.
I can remember driving to the homes of local stringers to retrieve their hand written correspondence and helping the typesetter decipher the submissions. I agree there is an opportunity and necessity for newspapers to continue this long-standing tradition in the future.
LikeLike
Steve…loved your writing on the Sentinel.
We were some of the “locals” you were chuckling about. My Grandparents (Perry Tinnell, Sr.) moved to Shen in 1939 from Braddyville. Lived 2 1/2 miles west of town just off highway 2. Then moved to “Sleepy Hollow” and my parents (Perry Tinnell, Jr.) moved to grandparent’s farm in 1943 after their marriage. My two sisters and I graduated from Farragut High School. 1963..1965..1970. Patti was all over the
Sentinel sports pages in 1970. She was a star guard for the Farragut Admiralettes. Mom’s
family from Shen too. Grandpa worked for
Earl May’s. Lived on W. Thomas. 1 block off highway 59. The folks moved in 1983 to Warren County. My husband’s nephew and wife are now at the Des Moines Register. Tom Perry and Carol Hunter. Thanks again for the memories. So very sorry to hear
about your nephew.
LikeLike
Small world, Beverly. My brother Don married an Admiralette (Pam Albright). And my mother-in-law worked at May’s. And I spent 10 years at the Des Moines Register.
LikeLike
Peggy Ostrem emailed me this response and gave me permission to post it as a comment here:
I have read — and reread — your today’s column and decided that I must respond. I will introduce myself; I am a long time resident of Iowa City (since I was graduated in 1950, so I’m considerably older than you) but am a product of Farragut, Iowa, and also worked at the Shenandoah Sentinel. My name then was Peggy Whitehill and during my summers when I was home from the University, I was society editor at the paper. I’m not sure today why Bob Tindall and Willard Archie let me take that position for just three months, but apparently the regular writer enjoyed having her summers off.
After my graduation I was a teacher of English and journalism in Iowa City for 26 years, and my mother in Farragut faithfully sent me clippings from the Sentinel (and later the Valley News) and I got so many chuckles from the local news. I’ll never forget one item. My dad was a patient at the nursing home in Shen as was the town’s banker, Bob Henstorf. Neither man was a barrel of laughs. Anyway, the item said that Irene Whitehill and Doris Henstorf has been in Shen to see two grumpy old men. They had been to see that movie, but the item didn’t specify that , and I’m sure everyone in Farragut fell off their chairs laughing. I could go on and on about many funny experiences there, but just wanted you to know I really can identify with your comments. I also enjoy your paper in general; keep it coming!
LikeLike
So, what’s going on in the Gazette newsroom today? Hearing rumors of layoffs…
LikeLike
I answered Wondering’s question in this post:
https://stevebuttry.wordpress.com/2009/02/24/a-reluctant-farewell-to-valued-colleagues/
LikeLike
Steve,
I enjoyed reading your comments on small town papers. I always enjoyed reading the papers from my parents’ hometowns–the Belleville, Kansas, Telescope and Cottonwood Falls, Kansas, Chase County Leader for all that smalltown local news. We city kids (Lawrence, KS) were so excited because we would get our names in the paper when we went to visit our grandma or cousins.
However, the way I stumbled onto your article was in looking for information on my dad’s cousin, Irene Whitehill. I was then delighted and surprised to see Irene and Herschel’s daughter, Peggy Ostrem, had chimed in on the blog. I’m not in touch with her and wonder if you would be kind enough to pass my email address along to her and ask if she would contact me.
Thanks in advance.
Bruce Lacey
San Francisco
LikeLike
Bruce, I have passed your email address on to Peggy Ostrem. I hope the two of you connect.
LikeLike
[…] I mentioned in an earlier column that my nephew Patrick was undergoing treatment for leukemia. He was released from a Boston […]
LikeLike
[…] us to develop personal content platforms that treat the big news in people’s lives as the big stories they are (in small circles), rather than boiling them down to formulaic announcements and agate listings. Most important, I […]
LikeLike
OK, Steve. I used to scorn those busybody gossips in Shen, too, (including my Mom) but also see things in a different light with the passing of years. I was embarrassed being the subject of many of those locals, especially the ones my mother wrote during her stint at the Sentinel! (During the years we were in college and early 20’s) Now that she has been at Elm Heights for about 8 years with dementia, I wish I could listen to her stories again. I enjoyed this article immensely!
How is Patrick?
LikeLike
Thanks, Marda. Some recent test results for Patrick were troubling. He had some more tests this week and his parents will be meeting with doctors tomorrow to learn more about his situation and the options.
LikeLike
[…] prayed and expressed concern and support for my nephew Patrick, whose battle against leukemia I wrote about in February and again in March after his bone-marrow […]
LikeLike
[…] February, I wrote a blog post about CaringBridge, asking my sister’s permission before posting it. I didn’t want to invade their privacy, even […]
LikeLike
[…] by Patrick Devlin’s parents to deliver the eulogy at Patrick’s funeral today. I have written before here about Patrick’s struggle with leukemia and his father’s use of CaringBridge […]
LikeLike
[…] death of my nephew, Patrick Devlin, and the World War II diary of my uncle, Frank Arnold. I first wrote about Patrick in a professional context, noting that CaringBridge was bringing me my most important news and […]
LikeLike
[…] continued my interest in social media, teaching workshops in Twitter and liveblogging, and using CaringBridge, Google tools, TripIt, SlideShare, Aardvark, YouTube and more social […]
LikeLike
[…] Steve Buttry talks about how CaringBridge is contributing the death of traditional newspapers […]
LikeLike
[…] Steve Buttry talks about how CaringBridge is contributing the death of traditional newspapers […]
LikeLike
[…] helped my sister’s family immeasurably. I wrote several blog posts in 2009 relating to the illness and death of my nephew Patrick Devlin. His eulogy still gets occasional traffic, which gives me a […]
LikeLike
[…] have written on occasion here about how CaringBridge brought important news about my nephew Patrick Devlin when he was battling leukemia in 2009 and after he died. I mentioned in my eulogy for Patrick that […]
LikeLike
[…] Personal news: Big news in small circles […]
LikeLike
[…] the illnesses of his children, Patrick and Kat. I posted twice in 2009 about John’s use of CaringBridge, and knew I needed to share my story there. (Patrick died of leukemia in 2009. Kat is thriving as a […]
LikeLike